Proposed tolls for Tauranga highway 'excessive'

NZ Transport Agency is proposing to toll the Takitimu North Link, which is set to open in 2028. Photo / NZTA

Proposed tolls on another Tauranga highway are “excessive” and “grossly unfair” given the city already has two of the country’s three toll roads, residents say.

Tauranga and Western Bay of Plenty residents are calling out NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi’s proposal to toll the Takitimu North Link (TNL) once it opens in 2028.

Construction of stage one, a 6.8km four-lane expressway between Tauranga and Te Puna stage, is under way.

NZTA is proposing a toll to cover maintenance costs and fund the construction of stage two.

Under the proposal, motorists in light vehicles using the stage one route would be charged $2.10 to $3.10 per use depending on the time of day, while heavy vehicles would pay $4.20 to $6.20.

Proposed tolls for stage two, which would complete the route from Ōmokoroa to Tauranga, increase to a maximum of $4.10 for light vehicles and $8.20 for heavy vehicles during peak hours.


Ōmokoroa community board member Chris Dever said the proposed toll prices are too expensive. Photo / Supplied

Ōmokoroa community board member Chris Dever did not have a problem with tolls, but the proposed prices were “excessive”.

Travelling from his Ōmokoroa home to Tauranga, including fuel, would cost him around $16 for the 20km journey.

“It shouldn’t be a significant amount of money, it should just be a little nibble every time you use the road.”

Dever also questioned the fairness of it, as Transmission Gully in Wellington and the Waikato Expressway were not tolled.

“That three of the four toll roads in New Zealand would all be in the Bay of Plenty seems grossly unfair.”

Takitimu Drive and the Tauranga Eastern Link (TEL) are both tolled, along with Auckland’s Northern Gateway.


Katikati / Waihī Beach councillor Rodney Joyce said NZTA needed to be careful not to price people off the road. Photo / John Borren

Katikati / Waihī Beach councillor Rodney Joyce said NZTA needed to be careful not to price people off the road.

If too many vehicles continued to use the current road - congestion-plagued State Highway 2 - it would end up costing ratepayers through maintenance costs.

“It’ll become a cost on ratepayers if it’s overused.”

The region also needed more than just the TNL to deal with its congestion and infrastructure deficit, he said.

Smartgrowth leadership group iwi representative Riki Nelson said the TNL would be a road of national significance and the “burden” of paying for it should not fall solely on Western Bay of Plenty.

“Our communities resent the fact that this Government is putting that burden on our local communities, on all the people that live and work, not just in Tauranga, but our wider region.”

People were already struggling due to the lack of investment over decades in infrastructure, said Nelson, who was also member of the NZTA northern Tauranga iwi advisory group.

The Port of Tauranga – New Zealand’s largest port – was a “significant asset,” and Nelson said the region added enough to the national economy to warrant investment in infrastructure.


The Takitimu North Link will link Tauranga and Te Puna. Photo / NZTA

Ōmokoroa resident Kevin Payne said the road should be tolled.

“Someone in Whangarei or Dunedin, why should their income be going to a road that 90% of the people using it are going to be from this district?

“That’s not fair, it’s not equitable.”

Payne is retired but travels to Tauranga three days a week to look after his grandchildren.

Jason Ponder said people already paid enough in fuel excise tax and road user charges, so it was not acceptable to add extra costs.

The Whakamārama resident owns a construction company and travels to Tauranga up to three times a day.

The tolls made it unaffordable so Ponder would just use the existing highway.

“The whole idea of doing that road is to reduce congestion and in doing so, it needs to be affordable.

“Taxing people in the way of tolls is just ridiculous.”


NZTA senior manager project services Jo Wilton said investment in infrastructure was needed for the growing region of Western Bay of Plenty. Photo / Mike Scott

NZTA senior manager project services Jo Wilton said the Government’s policy statement on transport introduced an expectation for NZTA to consider tolling for maintenance of all new roads, including roads of national significance.

The TNL was expected to move regional traffic and freight away from local roads, she said.

Modelling for 2031 showed 34,000 vehicles could travel between Tauranga and Ōmokoroa each day using both the TNL and existing state highway.

The annual population increase was 2% to 3% and the transport system needed investment to provide for the growth, she said.

Funding for stage one was secured but tolling the road would cover maintenance costs and support construction of stage two.

It also provided revenue to support other major infrastructure projects, she said.

If people travelled on the TNL and then onto Takitimu Drive or Tauranga Eastern Link they would pay the individual toll for each road, Wilton said.

The tolls would be removed when the cost of the road was recovered.

For Takitimu Drive the toll was expected to be removed in 2031 and the TEL was 2049. The TNL was proposed to be tolled for 35 years.

Proposed toll prices aimed to bring in sufficient revenue across the lifespan of the road to recoup the construction costs and contribute to maintenance and operation, Wilton said.

Public consultation on the tolls closes at 5pm on October 7. Submissions can be made via NZTA’s website.

Proposed tolls on Takitimu North Link

  • Under the proposal, a light vehicle trip would cost $3.10 one way during peak times (7-9am and 4-6pm) and $2.10 during off-peak times for stage one.

  • For heavy vehicles a peak-hour trip would cost $6.20 one way and $4.20 off-peak.

  • Proposed tolls for stage two if travelling from Ōmokoroa to Tauranga would be $4.10 for light vehicles at peak times and $3.10 off-peak, and $8.20 at peak for heavy vehicles and $6.20 off-peak.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

17 comments

really stupid

Posted on 24-09-2024 06:51 | By kiwi_brat2003

When it comes to toll roads I refuse to use and will go the slow way. Why you ask . Well I don't think we should pay 2x for a road (in fuel tax) or for the road they say is for the future but is 10 years to late. So the slow way will suffice and will add on extra for the trips.
Yes I agree that normal slow way will be damaged further and traffic will be disgusting but when you look at the other toll roads here they are under used solely due to the tolls on them. I would say less than 20% of all traffic uses them.


Give then Take

Posted on 24-09-2024 08:30 | By 2up

You got your TAX cut which should cover all these new living expenses:
increased ACC, Tolls, what's next from this Government?
That's right across the board service and standard of living cuts.


So the old trick

Posted on 24-09-2024 08:42 | By an_alias

Start by introducing the idea of MORE tolls being possible, then look we are doing it regardless of feedback, then oh lets make the TOLLs really high. If some complain, we can reduce them to our target amount and say oh look its cheaper now.
Once its tolled it wont EVER change.
You think you pay road tax already, Nah, we want more....


Toll both roads

Posted on 24-09-2024 08:46 | By Samwell

Toll both but make the old road a bit cheaper


I simply will avoid using it.......

Posted on 24-09-2024 09:06 | By Bruja

for two reasons. 1) I simply can't afford that on Super. 2) On principle, we pay Rego and Licence and WOF fees now. Enough!!!! NZTA is one of the most poorly-run, mismanaged entities in this country. Stop the waste!!!! Stop the incompetence. Stop the excessive salaries and staffing levels.


Worried citizen here

Posted on 24-09-2024 09:20 | By Saul

Kiwis are struggling to pay bills, rates.....
Councils are broke...
New Zealand is broke.....
The financial system is breaking down....
Reset on the way!


Poor form

Posted on 24-09-2024 09:55 | By Astoreth

I think it highly disingenuous of the government to talk about tolling roads after construction has started; any such debate should be had before any physical works are planned, let alone started.


and...and...

Posted on 24-09-2024 12:43 | By Batch

Don't forget the "congestion tax" is also on the way...might be cheaper to stay at home.


Lest we forget.

Posted on 24-09-2024 14:10 | By SonnyJim

Tauranga Eastern Link (TEL) cannot be counted as a toll-road burden because, we wanted it, we voted that it be a toll-road - enjoy it. As a nostalgic reminder, take the free toll-road bypass occasionally - to experience a bit of history and buy a pie or coffee in Te Puke. You can't do that on the tolled bypass.


Yes to the Road, No to the "Tolls" (Taxes)

Posted on 24-09-2024 15:46 | By CRAZYBARRACUDA

Toll roads enable projects that would otherwise be sidelined and boosts overseas investment. For most people this looks like paying taxes to help build a road you won't use for thirty years. Basically toll roads make sense for a National Government (indifferent to most Kiwi's) but everyday people won't benefit from at all - at least for thirty years, by which time the road probably could have been fully funded by tax payers and built with no user tolls.

I see the "why should I pay for a road I don't use" argument tossed around a lot. It's actually because all New Zealanders are equals and everyone has the right to access. The road isn't necessary for access. However, once you understand the significant growth in the region and the fact the road links directly to the busiest port in New Zealand the economic opportunity becomes obvious.


value

Posted on 24-09-2024 17:44 | By Duegatti

I don't mind paying a toll for good, long distance highways. We paid about €20 - €30 from Rome to Naples.
But we don't get that here. We get a few kms tacked onto an existing free road, or that abysmal rort that is Takitimu Dr. Single lane toll roads?
Only in NZ.
So this latest nonsense has to be stopped. NZTA are soaking us in Tauranga enough. Put a toll on Transmission Gully instead.
But, wait , politicians use that road, don't they?


The Patchwork Toll Road

Posted on 24-09-2024 18:50 | By Watchdog

I wonder why we are paying tolls on the current toll road from Tauranga Crossing to the Mount. Look at the road we have to drive on. It is a patchwork quilt and will not get any better for a long time yet. It is time to scrap the tolls on this road. It is a third world country road at best. AND we are limited to 70 KMH for much of the way. We are being extorted. So KILL THE TOLL, get Takitimu North finished and when it is ALL complete charge an affordable toll. Compare this link to the Eastern Link Toll cost. The distance and cost are far superior for a lower cost.


Perhaps

Posted on 25-09-2024 12:11 | By Merlin

Perhaps they could get their priorities right about infrastructure when 1.4 billion was given to tax relief to Landlords Etc and use it for infrastructure. 3 toll roads in Tauranga is absolutely ridiculous. Next ACC fees will go up as already rego fees has.Etc Etc.


NZTA failing

Posted on 25-09-2024 12:28 | By PGC

I don't have a problem with a toll road if it means we get modern, safe and fast roads quicker than the usual funding route. What I do object to is paying a full price toll on a road that is down to one lane and 70km/h while construction work is done. What is even more annoying is that (on the TEL) this construction work should have been anticipated and done at the time of construction only a few short years ago. By paying my toll to NZTA I am entering in to a contract with them, which they are not upholding.


Hmmm

Posted on 25-09-2024 16:55 | By Let's get real

I just don't understand some people.
We don't NEED a museum, community hub, new library etc, we NEED infrastructure (roading) but now that it is being built we have people who are against USER-PAYS.
Why should we care whether you're not going to use it and would prefer to sit in traffic..? When it's there, you have an alternative option. And anyway, I believe that most of those using the bypass will not be locals, but commercial vehicles and trucking companies.
Let's start getting our priorities straight and support the introduction of much needed infrastructure rather than banging on about fees that you don't have to pay.
USER-PAYS must be the watchword.


Who's getting taken for a ride?

Posted on 25-09-2024 17:22 | By PJ-Bethlehem

Oh, give us a break......seriously.... that much? If you have to, make them all $2.00, for cars... $5.00 for heavy vehicles, all day.

BUT, answer me this.... why is there no toll on the Waikato Expressway, no toll on Transmission Gully...does the expression "Pork Barreling" ring any bells in Wellington.
Just keep this up guys......we have long memories.

Peter


Wow

Posted on 27-09-2024 11:12 | By Deccy

I live in Tararua, we're 9 months away from the Manawatu Gorge replacement road opening and have learned in the last month that they plan to toll it - at $4.30 for light vehicles and $8.60 for heavy vehicles EACH WAY.
Our road was fully paid for by the Labour Government and now that National hasn't budgeted properly, we get charged again.
Thank goodness you good folk get a discounted travel period.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.