Fortunes are continually being spent on cycle lanes, so why do they remain dangerous and put cyclists' lives at risk?
Bevan Wait cycles into work most days and questions the safety of cycle lanes in Tauranga.
“I cycle into Basestation in the CBD and multiple times I’ve found the council has put roadwork signs in the middle of the cycle lane.”
When roadwork signs are placed in the cycle lane, cyclists are forced to go around the signs and onto the road.
“In most cases, Council requires contractors to keep cycleways clear of signs or provide an alternative space for people to use, however sometimes there isn’t enough space to maintain the cycleway and the amount of traffic management needed for the work to be carried out safely,” says Tauranga City Council acting manager of transportation infrastructure outcomes Kelvin Hill.
“In these situations, a 30km/h speed restriction is put in place that requires cycles and cars to share the road for a short distance.”
Cycle lanes are in place to create a space that separates the cyclists from the cars.
“I just feel it’s all a bit hypocritical when they’re spending god knows how many millions on cycleways supposedly to keep cyclists safe but then they’re doing stuff like this,” says Bevan.
He has made several complaints to the council and no real changes have been made.
“I’ve contacted them about it multiple times and they keep doing it,” says Bevan.
“This situation is avoided wherever possible,” says Kelvin.
“If cyclists feel that contractors aren’t complying with their traffic management plan, they are invited to notify Council to remedy the situation.”
“Last time they moved them, but then they just keep doing it,” says Bevan.
“I’ve talked to other cyclists at work and shown them pictures and they’ve said they’ve seen this sort of thing multiple times as well.”
A lot of cycle lanes are placed on busy roads such as Cameron Road and Totara Street.
“The road is so busy, so dangerous. The cyclists are forced to go out onto the road, it’s crazy,” says Bevan.
Kelvin says council is committed to the safety of all people who cycle in the city.
“This includes working towards futureproofing the cycle network to make it safer, more comfortable and provide better connections to local and city-wide destinations.
“Tauranga’s population is expected to grow by up to 78,000 people over the next 50 years and transport options will need to evolve to meet this growth.
“There is already significant congestion in places, and as there is no space to build new roads, it is vital that more people are able to get around safely and in ways that don’t add to the city’s carbon emissions, such as cycling, walking, and catching a bus.
“This will keep traffic flowing for freight movement and people who need to drive and create a more sustainable future for Tauranga,” says Kelvin.
Bevan says he is confused as to why they placed cycle lanes on Cameron Road and Totara Street which are some of the busiest roads with a lot of traffic.
“Totara Street has got logging trucks,” he says.
Kelvin says one of the other ways council helps to improve cycle safety is through the work of the Travel Safe team which provides cycling education programmes.
“Travel Safe’s new February to April calendar of free cycling activities for riders of all levels across Tauranga and the Western Bay is available at www.mytauranga.co.nz/timetocycle,” says Kelvin.
“People are getting knocked off their bikes left, right and centre. I play touch rugby and I just found out one of the guys was knocked off his bike on the holidays and is still recovering,” says Bevan.
“I don’t feel like the amount of money they’re spending on cycle ways… I do wonder if they’ve got the best interest if cyclists at heart.”
20 comments
Close the roads
Posted on 25-01-2024 07:22 | By Wigan
Really feeling for Tauranga cyclists here. I don't know why the council just doesn't close the roads completely to motorised traffic every time they need to do a bit of maintenance!
The good news then would be they would not have to put out thousands of cones. Just half a dozen at each end of the road... Job done.
AND, just as a FYI, it seems cyclists don't really care about safety anyway, just ask the several I have seen lifting their bikes over the fence & NOT using the up/down/round/under billion $$$ cycle lane between the Wairoa river & Bethlehem.
Who pays
Posted on 25-01-2024 07:49 | By Angels
From my understanding these bike lanes are funded from road user charges for cars , trucks etc. bikes don’t pay anything. We have the most bike bs of any city in Nz. When Google only 3% of population ride bikes yet use what percentage of roadway. Whiners never happy.
The amount a bike spare is more than ample.
Cycle Lanes
Posted on 25-01-2024 07:56 | By Pundit
We are all sick of the council putting so much money into cycle lanes, probably for different reasons though.! Maybe there should be a cycling competency test that cyclist have to do to be able to ride a bike? If a cyclist is not competent enough to cycle on the road for a short distance around a couple of cones, then how do cyclist get on when there is no cycle lane.?
Anyway, it won't be long before the whole CBD is deserted so you will have the road to yourselves.
Use The Cycle Lanes
Posted on 25-01-2024 08:07 | By Thats Nice
It's not unusual to see cyclists NOT using the cycle lanes and riding on the road. If there's a cycleway for them then they should have to use it and keep off the roads, after all look at how much money has been spent building these cycle lanes.
I can understand
Posted on 25-01-2024 08:30 | By Bruja
this stuff aboout the cones in cycle lanes. Just CAN'T happen, that's crazy BUT I also want to know why so many cyclists are NOT using the cycle lane going down Totara Street. It looks ideal to me (from a cyclist point of view). I travel in my car down there and feel unsafe because of the trucks. I would NEVER cycle on the road down Totara.
Another Cyclist's Perspective
Posted on 25-01-2024 10:09 | By DEC123
As a fellow cyclist, I resonate with Bevan's frustrations. Placing roadwork signs, pedestrians, cars, and the left-hand tires of large vehicles in cycle lanes is not only inconvenient but also jeopardizes our safety. It's disheartening that despite investing in cycleways for safety, these issues persist. The irony in showcasing an image of a stylish yet unsafe bike raises concerns about the overall approach. As cyclists, we need more than just lanes; we need consistent efforts to ensure these lanes are respected and kept clear. It's crucial for the council to address these persistent challenges, collaborate with the cycling community, and uphold their commitment to creating safer and more sustainable transportation options. Let's work together to make Tauranga's roads genuinely cyclist-friendly and promote a safer environment for everyone.
Cameron Road
Posted on 25-01-2024 10:19 | By Captain Hottie
I don't get this bloke moaning Cameron Road is unsafe. Cyclists don't share the road with vehicles now, they have their own lane on the footpath. If anyone should feel unsafe it's pedestrians as the cycling fraternity literally still won't stay in their lane, still using the clearly marked pedestrian side.
The Master
Posted on 25-01-2024 12:10 | By Ian Stevenson
Motorists, as road users, pay a lot of tax and so have a right to be on the road and make full use of it. Cyclists pay ZERO, nothing yet demand endless crazy expensive "cycle-lanes" and priority on the roads.
Obviously there is a serious issue here, the commentary lacks: - reality, common-sense and practicality 24/7.
Cycle Lanes vs Paths
Posted on 25-01-2024 12:23 | By Wundrin
Confusion has been generated by the likes of TCC around the difference between cycle lanes (on road) and cycle paths (separate from road, as on Cameron Rd), and the different rules which apply to each. While turning traffic must give way to cyclists in a cycle lane, a quick search of the net suggests that TCC's assertion that turning motorists must legally give way to cyclists using the cycle path has no basis in law - although there does appear to be an intention to change that law in the near future. The most endangered species in all this seems to be the pedestrians, who risk being mowed down by cyclists when stepping out of shops on the west side of Cameron Rd, likewise those that dare to walk on bike-ridden footpaths in their own neighbourhood.
The Master
Posted on 25-01-2024 12:24 | By Ian Stevenson
TCC said that the stage 1 "upgrades" (very inappropriate label) were to improve safety. I agree that has been a complete abject failure before even on paper, never mind the $100m odd wasted doing whatever?
Just another TCC project, dreamed up, schemed, no objectives achieved, budget blowouts and some... Can anyone say that they are surprised here?
Move the signs
Posted on 25-01-2024 13:10 | By Blasta
As a motorist, I see no difference between the signs being in the middle of the cycle lane or in the middle of the car/truck lane.
Especially the way TCC prioritises cycles over vehicles.
Therefore move the signs into the middle of the lanes?
Whah!!!
Posted on 25-01-2024 13:22 | By Kauritatahi
And don't go riding your bike on the footpath because you think that will be 'safer' either!!
Riding bikes (especially e-bikes and other powered transport) on the footpath is totally illegal (except for posties) and unsafe, yet this illegal practice is rampant in Tauranga. Council transport staff are loath to admit this or do anything about it, but it is the law. (Land Transport (Road User) Rule 2004, section 11.11). There is no longer any exemption for children, or bikes with wheels smaller than 355mm, - since about May 2021. The problem is that any idiot - without knowing the road rules - can ride a bike around the city without first providing any proof of training, responsibility, or common sense, or contributing to the roading network costs. And it shows.
If a cyclist
Posted on 25-01-2024 14:31 | By nerak
would think about it, perhaps they could take their backside off the seat, dismount, and ever so very carefully WALK around these heinous interruptions. I seem to recall an inordinate amount of pressure from cyclists to get what they wanted, now they want more? Of course, a cyclist could always throw their bike on one of the many empty buses if they knew there was an interruption to their passage coming up. Most interruptions - cones, are in place for a few days, or more. Such a shame to see such vast amount of parking space lost, cyclists seldom seen in a lane dedicated to them, and folk upset they don't have what they want. And Captain Hottie's right, too many cyclists seen on dedicated pedestrian path, and they don't want to respect pedestrians. What is with that?
Another cyclist
Posted on 25-01-2024 14:55 | By JFL
I too share concerns about these excessive cycle lanes. As a cyclist I must now pause at most crossings and contend with multiple obtructions. My trip has been slowed. I know, millions has been spent for me, and the outcome is worse. Its not what i want or need. I bike for my health, convenience (hate the congestion) and to do my bit for climate. Like it or not i believe the multiple madnesses of us all choosing to propell ourselves short distances in 2T of steel will come back to bite us (climate, economy, health spring to mind). My challenge to moanie car drivers is to think beyond your immediate convenience to the big picture and appreciate that the nuisance bike is not clogging your road, is less likely to consume your public health dollar and might help postpone the worst of climate change.
Crazy Cycle Lanes
Posted on 25-01-2024 15:35 | By Paul W2
The craziest cycle lanes would be the ones along Cameron Road where the cyclists have the right of way over left turning vehicles into streets along Cameron Road. One would expect the cyclist to have to give way as they have better visibility of vehicle turning than the drivers have of cyclists on their left. Most like will take a serious accident before something is done with this crazy situation.
Cycle ways and speed
Posted on 25-01-2024 15:46 | By oceans
Who goes 30 KPH through road constructions? NOONE. If anything most drivers go over the normal 50MPH. Today I was driving along cameron road with my cruise control sat on 50. A car at the back of me couldn't wait to pass. He did pass illegally and gave me the finger when he passed. Where are the cameras? where are the police? where are the plain cars? These arrogant people need to be caught.
Love the debate
Posted on 25-01-2024 16:12 | By Wigan
This is great to read the too & fro between cyclist & motorist.
EVERYONE hates the way the footpaths, cycle lanes and roads are being re-structured.
Well, except the "huge-money" spending non-elected council...
They are just sitting in a little circle patting each other on the back for such a job well done :(
Really seems like a round table between all the people that have to suffer this BS would have saved $millions. But we cant have that can we?
Priority
Posted on 26-01-2024 09:53 | By Slipper
Priority should always be given to motor vehicles, that’s why the roads are there.
Humanity is the goal
Posted on 26-01-2024 12:25 | By olemanriver
Bike lanes are still unsafe. Sorta half measures have been implemented as is the NZ tradition. If it was safe you would see more kids bicycling to school, and more people bicycling to work. What you do see in Tauranga are half measures to try to stop bikes and pedestrians becoming hood ornaments too often. The tradition of fast hard left turns, speed down Cameron Rd, and crossing mid road by pedestrians is difficult to change. We became used to danger and speed. Bicyclists are good for the nation and the city .. we should do more to get people out of cars. Safe bike lanes are humane improvements.
@Wigan
Posted on 26-01-2024 21:53 | By morepork
Hear! Hear! I endorse your succint statement 100%. As you say, a round table of affected parties could have saved millions (not to mention also giving us a far better set of solutions...). I would like to see a period of discussion in fora like this one for an agreed period of time, and then the professionals take it on board and release draft plans for comment. NO WORK starts until there is consensus and agreement on what is planned. The drafts are finalized and there are some options. We vote on the options and everybody accepts responsibility for the winner. That's the one we actually build. (I see this model or a similar one being used by Council for all capital expenditure over an agreed amount, say, $50 million.) Morepork for Mayor!!!
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.