Shortfall: Doctors warn fees will need to rise

Shane Reti. Photo: RNZ/Nick Monro

Primary health providers are rejecting Health NZ / Te Whatu Ora's increase of four per cent to core general practice funding.

They say the government is shortchanging GPs - whose margins are already thin - as well as their patients, whose ability to pay more for a doctor's visit is already frayed.

Health Minister Dr Shane Reti says the current government has invested more money in health than ever before, and in a challenging financial environment.

General Practice New Zealand chair Dr Bryan Betty tells Morning Report the health agency's offer has been strongly rejected by GPs.

He says over the past year the cost of running a general practice has gone up about nine per cent - bringing the total deficit now to about 14 per cent.

"We need to understand that general practice is not fully funded," Betty says.

"So the patient does have to pay to see a doctor to actually cover the cost of delivering healthcare, the extra cost. So this year the fees that patients pay to see the doctor will have to go up in order to cover the cost of continuing to deliver healthcare."

The government has allowed GPs to up their prices by up to 7.76 per cent, short of the nine per cent increase in costs, Betty claims.

"The basic problem here is what's happened over the last 10 years is there's been a growing underlying funding shortfall that's developed. This was identified in something called the Sapare report in 2022, which estimated that over the previous 10 years that general practice was underfunded to the tune of about nine per cent. That's risen to about 14 per cent we think this year, and as a result of that, these increases do not cover that underlying deficit.

"So we've got real real concerns that some practices may not be viable going forward, and we've seen examples of that start to pop up around the country. So this viability of general practices in certain areas is of great great concern at this point."

In a statement, Reti acknowledges "the challenges facing primary care".

"The total primary care, public and population health appropriation uplift for 2024/25 is an additional $531 million. For the 2024/25 year, the Health NZ Board has approved an additional $223 million for annual price uplifts for the primary and community sector across commissioning, along with an additional $117m held to respond to increase in demand due largely to population growth.

"An additional $16.4m will be provided to Pacific and public health services in sector uplifts and demand.

"So while recognising pressures, those are very significant sums of public money, and this government has invested more money in health than ever before, in a challenging financial environment."

Reti saysd the Ministry of Health is also working on policy and changes "need to achieve comprehensive and accessible primary and community healthcare to better prevent ill health and support the wellbeing of people in New Zealand in the longer-term".

-RNZ.

5 comments

The Master

Posted on 19-07-2024 16:47 | By Ian Stevenson

Perhaps the GP's should disclose publicly the facts and truth about just how each doctor gets from the MOH annually + what they charge in fees as well + what costs that they must incur.

That way, the taxpayers will then know what they are paying for.


Not Justifiable.

Posted on 19-07-2024 18:31 | By Yadick

GP's have become a business through franchising and must therefore show a good profit. GP's book out 15 minute appointments at an average of $65 per adult visit, (some book out 10 minute increments but let's not get too greedy). Do the math's, that's $260.00 per hour. Who can justify that they're worth that sort of astronomical money, (apart from the Commorons)? On a 40hr week that's $10,400.00 per GP . . .
Yeah, fees need to rise - REALLY? How can their margins be thin for sitting in the chair?
Perhaps hospital ED's are overrun because of the greed of GP's.


Consequences of Increased Fees

Posted on 20-07-2024 07:10 | By Thats Nice

If you raise the fee of going to the doctors, then A & E will see even more people needing medical assistance although not necessarily an emergency.


Not justified I agree

Posted on 20-07-2024 13:19 | By Jellybean54

Totally agree with Yadick. Our Dr charges about $90 a visit for a paltry 10 minutes. And even then it's even more for a letter etc. Any increase is NOT justified. Recently received an email saying if you wanted to talk to the Dr about more than 2 things to book a double appointment!! Unbelievable. So out of touch.


Rip off

Posted on 20-07-2024 14:56 | By Patmac

I recently went to my doctor and before my predicament had been completely finished she changed the subject in my allocated 10 minutes to discuss something she wanted to talk about and then had the audacity to tell me we are out of time and if we don't finished I shall have to charge you another 5 minutes. I immediately left but won't be going back any time soon,my confidence in doctors has gone.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.