Support for further Civic Precinct development

There is majority Council support for further Civic Precinct development. File Photo.

A majority of Tauranga City Council elected members have voted to proceed with the construction of the planned Civic Whare, Exhibition and Museum project, which is a key part of the Te Manawataki o Te Papa city centre revitalisation initiative.

At its meeting on Monday, the Mayor and Councillors voted 7:2 in favour of proceeding with the $128 million project, which will provide a cohesive suite of cultural and civic amenities on the Civic Precinct – the area bounded by Willow, Wharf, Hamilton and Durham Streets.

Mayor Mahé Drysdale said the differing views expressed by Councillors illustrate that the recently-elected Council brings its own approach to investment decision-making, but that there was nevertheless solid support for the cultural, social and economic advances Te Manawataki o Te Papa will deliver for the city centre and the wider community.

“Given that the enabling works for this project, including site preparation, foundations and materials purchased for the building, are already nearing completion, there was a strong rationale for continuing with construction,” Mahé explains.

“The ‘sunk costs’ of that enabling work total around $20 million and if we discontinued the project now, the potential legal costs, loss of committed external contributions to the overall development and potential impacts on wider city centre and stakeholder confidence would have been significant.

“In short, the benefits of proceeding far outweigh the alternative option, which would incur significant costs and not represent good value for money which we’re determined to deliver for ratepayers.”

Drysdale said TECT’s promised $21 million contribution to the museum component of the project is dependent on there being no significant changes to the overall Te Manawataki o Te Papa projects, while a $12.1 million grant provided as part of the previous Labour Government’s water service reforms would likely have to be repaid if the project did not proceed.

The Civic Precinct projects also include construction of a Library and Community Hub facility, which is well underway and expected to be completed in 2026, plus associated landscaping and streetscape improvements and the recently-completed upgrading of Masonic Park as the key link to the transformed waterfront reserve. Its aim is to create a vibrant, safe, accessible and thriving city centre which will draw locals and visitors to the area, providing much-needed cultural, social and economic stimuli.

The land underlying the Civic Precinct is owned by Te Manawataki o Te Manawa Trust, a Council-controlled organisation (CCO) jointly-governed by Otamataha Trust (on behalf of the original owners) and Council.

Delivery of the various Civic Precinct projects is overseen by Te Manawataki o Te Papa Limited, a CCO made up of independent directors with significant experience in development and construction.

Their recommendation was that the project budget - $92 million for site preparation and building construction and $36.4 million for non-construction costs (such as consenting requirements, legal and design costs, furniture and fittings and contingency and cost escalation provisions) – be accepted.

Speaking on behalf of the Otamataha Trust, Mana Whenua and Tangata Whenua Puhirake Ihake said “We wholeheartedly support and approve the continuation of this project”.

A number of speakers in the Public Forum section of Monday’s meeting also expressed strong support for the project.

Mary Dillon, former Tauranga City Councillor said “This project is central to the entire wider Te Manawataki o Te Papa project and is the major expression of our joint cultural heritage. This development is our first highly visible integrated presentation of our cultural origins as people of Tauranga Moana”.

The overall budget for Te Manawataki o Te Papa is $306 million, of which a maximum of $151.5 will come from rates-funded borrowing.

The balance will come from external grants, philanthropic contributions and the net value of Council asset realisations (after any associated debt has been repaid).

Resolutions adopted by the Council include confirmation that the Civic Whare, Exhibition and Museum facility should proceed as programmed in the 2024-34 Long-term Plan; and authorisation for the Chief Executive to enter contracts on the Council’s behalf for the stage 2 construction works.

15 comments

Wonderful

Posted on 10-12-2024 07:46 | By AJSommerville

Great to see, I cannot wait to explore our history and to see our city continue to mature. Thank you to the Council for taking this step.


Loaded

Posted on 10-12-2024 08:13 | By Yadick

Crikey, the more I read of this project the more I feel it is loaded with pocket liners.
TECT’s promised $21 million contribution to the . . . project is dependent on . . . no significant changes to the overall projects . . . then 12.1 million from Labor Water reforms would likely be lost even though a replacement project would need it . . .
I still question how an unnecessary 1 visit mueseum, empty meeting halls (of which we have many unused already), and a so-called 'community hub' are going to transform our shopless city to a thriving metropolis. Wasn't the promise, that the Farmers building would do that? How's that working out?
Also, how much more is this cultural influenced 'everything' costing us. We are supposed to be one. Not everything needs a cultural influence and (meaningless to most) name.


Hey Mahé

Posted on 10-12-2024 08:19 | By Yadick

Just a thought for you, when are you going to give us parking and shops and clean streets again. Just those three alone would go a long way to bringing people back to our Council induced abandoned city centre.


White Elephant

Posted on 10-12-2024 09:24 | By Fernhill22

Unfortunately, the previous commissioners have now put ratepayers into a position where there is no choice but to proceed with this White Elephant of a project. It's a project that brings no economic benefit to the ratepayers but saddles them with a huge amount of debt & ongoing losses as none of these things like a museum or library are ever going to make a profit. Given the lack of parking in the CBD & one-way roads/ closed roads no one will be able to visit any way. This was the time for the new council to make a stand against the old regime & to grow some balls, but they have massively failed their ratepayers' best interests in this instance.


Postive news

Posted on 10-12-2024 10:37 | By Informed

This is great news for the city and CBD.

Though it does make me laugh that people are still complaining about parking, even though we all know that there isn't a parking shortage in the CBD. I guess some people just need something to complain about.


Fantastic!

Posted on 10-12-2024 10:37 | By WestieMum

So pleased that arts and culture are now going to get recognition in this city that has always been sports/beach dominated. City centers everywhere are having to evolve – the days of them being a shopping precinct are long gone – thanks to malls and online shopping. If you want a revitalised CBD then it needs to be about experience, not shopping and parking. I can’t wait to eventually step inside the long overdue Museum show casing our taonga and history that has been squirreled away for far too long and see the exhibitions that will come now we have a place for them. Thank you, Council.


A difficult decision

Posted on 10-12-2024 11:44 | By morepork

If we take a longer view, it will probably be a good thing. I consulted to an American company once where a particular project had been very badly planned and mis-managed. The main offenders were very smug that it COULDN'T be cancelled because there was already $30 million dollars invested. This article made me remember it... After several weeks of review and discussion the painful decision was taken to cut the loss and cancel it. I believe that was a right decision, but the CBD project is a slightly different case, and if we get tangible benefits with costs spread over a longer period, and the project tightly controlled, with a stated budget of no more than $300 million, it will be part of the growth and advance of Tauranga. The Commission made sure our options were limited and we have to live with it.


The Master

Posted on 10-12-2024 12:04 | By Ian Stevenson

@ AJSommerville

Based on the facts here, you would seem to be a little off track, the true history of New Zealand will not be presented, it is intended to be a creative, generated and desired history.


The Master

Posted on 10-12-2024 12:07 | By Ian Stevenson

@ Yadick

I think you missed the memo, carparking in the CBD is history.

Therefore cars/vehicles ditto

The CBD is to be "CAR-LESS" ASAP.

NB: What TCC don't seem to realise is that will result in the final death of the CBD... they will of course continue to "Plan" and "think (try but fail) of the 1348th Civic revitalization plan... each and everyone better than the one before @ a cost of millions each...


The Master

Posted on 10-12-2024 12:09 | By Ian Stevenson

@ "ILL" informed...

Seems you are perhaps a 100 years or so out of date?

Although, shortly you will be right, the CBD will have been totally destroyed, businesses will have all left and so then the remains 1-2 carparks left will be empty 24/7...


The Master

Posted on 10-12-2024 12:12 | By Ian Stevenson

There is no way the spend will be on budget, the couple of grants ($33-34m or so) and selling off TCC ratepayer paid for assets will not generate $150+m, so ratepayers debt will be huge.

The OPEX will be huge... Debt will be huge... One can expect that TCC rates will increase 3-5x by 2034...

So all you Museum lovers (few) all citizens will be paying dearly for this crazy stuff...


Fantastic

Posted on 10-12-2024 12:15 | By cbd dweller

So pleased to hear this is going forward. The upgrade to Tauranga is long overdue.
Let’s move on from complaining about the commissioners and make some positive choices. We have plenty of shopping mallls let’s revitalise Tauranga away from that mentality. Re-parking there is plenty …


Hmmm

Posted on 10-12-2024 14:49 | By Let's get real

What else are we to expect from council offices anywhere around the country.
They demand money from the community to service the cost of the essential services needed by residents, but spend millions on vanity projects and empty spaces. All while auctioning off the provision of those very essential services to outside contractors to make a profit from residents.
They have relinquished refuse removal, added additional billing for water services and regional council, contracted out water, sewerage and green space mantainance and services.
We don't have a council, we have a management structure to manage the management of the private contractors.
What are we paying hundreds of people to do, when all council services are contracted out.
We're paying people to spend money on empty spaces and build a magnificent empire to their glory.

IT'S A CITY, NOT A THEME PARK.


Referendum

Posted on 11-12-2024 12:43 | By Angels

YA RIGHT
Council doesn’t listen when 80 say something.
They have selective hearing and doing.
Whatever we say matters not.


Great News

Posted on 11-12-2024 22:34 | By Inmediasres

Great news!

Well spoken by:

AJSommerville
Informed
WestieMum
cbd dweller

And of course, the usual suspects are whinging as they do 🙄


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.